 鲜花( 1181)  鸡蛋( 48)
|
本帖最后由 小黄 于 2009-12-21 13:39 编辑 9 y: Q: N: B% `/ y& \
你也别整呢些弯弯绕了。你就说吧:CIVIC和卡车撞,谁比谁更吸能?谁比谁更容易死?
& ]8 x$ c- z9 r8 `7 E+ W3 @降龙十八掌 发表于 2009-12-21 11:33 
; @4 M* y- A+ Q$ iThere is no data available. If you do have some, please share. But please don't make up scenarios and data yourself, that's 意淫. Use a published source, or statistically controlled experiment.
( O( H0 l. g! A0 x8 k% A( C2 T/ [8 }, u
From the existing data, there are 3 types of death:
3 ~5 S* F' z. N/ i- l' p7 ?1) MV: multi vehicle collision, like when a Civic hits another car/truck! G3 f$ i% H' F& |( U7 q5 I8 f
2) SV: single vehicle, like hitting a tree, or roll over6 V- e! ]6 ~* x) R: U
3) SV Roll: roll over, this a sub set of SV. H+ [# d$ b6 x5 I, N
& S- ?; k/ k7 M0 s5 J+ V6 t
For Honda Civic:( e# }0 [& |* ]
MV 342 \9 d/ M% V- i* Y, K
SV 33
. h( A4 k7 H" y' rSV Roll 13
! c* P$ {2 l! h3 e) m: G1 U8 I J/ ?" I( ?1 u
For Ford F150 (including super cab, crew cab):1 w4 F7 N- F' l0 t, G; {( r" Q
MV 28~34+ n2 `# y* F5 v! T
SV 79~94' z( Q0 |1 Z5 y
SV Roll 48~828 V+ B" p- ^$ t
6 v' R3 c5 G0 `$ O( X* l' x' fFor Chevy Silverado 1500:: o( W3 B7 u4 E* y- W
MV 40
$ o! V: |( B6 QSV 85' a9 T0 ?% `: |! x8 q
SV Roll 61
( S/ }& a' s3 T+ r* K, F, b" E; X2 G1 S6 Q: c
As you can see, not only would the trucks roll over more easily, they don't perform better even in a vehicle on vehicle collision. So, yeah, Civic is definitely safer than F150 or Silverado. |
|